“Attaching” judgment to a bankruptcy notice: lessons in semantics

Articles, Restructuring + Insolvency

In Mastronardo v Commonwealth Bank of Australia Limited [2019] FCAFC 127 the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia recently provided some insight into the formalities of issuing bankruptcy notices.

Mr and Mrs Mastronardo were each served with bankruptcy notices by the Commonwealth Bank of Australia. The Mastronados did not contend service was defective, nor did they mount any argument that the judgment relied upon had not been served with the relevant notices. Rather, the Mastronados each argued that the bankruptcy notices were a nullity as the final judgments upon which the bankruptcy notices were issued were not attached to the bankruptcy notice at the time of being issued by the Official Receiver.

In this regard, the Mastronados relied upon the wording of the prescribed Form 1 bankruptcy notice that the claim the subject of the notice be identified by reference to “the amount as per the attached final judgment…”  to argue that the final judgment was not attached to the bankruptcy notices issued by the Official Receiver to he Commonwealth Bank of Australia (for service on the Mastronados).

The argument was not accepted by Griffiths J sitting at first instance. The Mastronardos appealed.

The argument that a final judgment needed to be “attached” to the bankruptcy notice when issued by the Official Receiver was also rejected on appeal for the following reasons:

The Court provided the following summary in respect to the argument advanced by the appellants:

“Reliance upon dictionary definitions of the term “attach”, with respect, merely provide assistance but not answers. That is principally because the use of language in the context of electronic communications has, perhaps, outstripped the commonly understood meaning of words employed in a non-computer era.” 

The Court dismissed the appeal, ordering the Mastronados to pay the bank’s costs of the appeal.

If you have any questions, please contact us on (02) 9324 5300 or online (below).

People

With the technical skills, diverse backgrounds and practical experience to match, our teams care about their clients.


Our Expertise

We have a strong reputation for providing specialist, market-leading advice in the practices we offer. Our teams are experts in their field and provide an unrivalled service to clients.


News

We want to share our knowledge with you. A collection of news and insights into those areas in which we specialise.


Resources

We offer a relevant, easy access platform that allows clients and colleagues to gain access to relevant resources.


Contact Us

With offices in Sydney and Melbourne, our team pride themselves on always being available for their clients.


Careers

We are collaborative, respectful and inclusive. Recruiting the best talent is only half of the equation; providing a culture that enables development is the other.

See our exciting opportunities available for graduates, lawyers, legal support staff and business services professionals.